理论教育 编辑或审稿人的误解多次拒稿 作者如何申辩

编辑或审稿人的误解多次拒稿 作者如何申辩

时间:2023-07-05 理论教育 版权反馈
【摘要】:如果编辑或审稿人因为对稿件的内容理解有误而做出不能说服作者的决定,作者可以对拒稿的理由逐一反驳,以期得到重新处理。

编辑或审稿人的误解多次拒稿 作者如何申辩

如果编辑或审稿人因为对稿件的内容理解有误而做出不能说服作者的决定,作者可以对拒稿的理由逐一反驳,以期得到重新处理(前提是认真审视稿件的表达方式,修改表达不够清楚或有可能产生歧义的文字)。

例1:对编辑初审退稿的申辩

Dear Editor,

I just received your information on rejecting our manuscript,entitled“***”(Ref.No.***),without an opportunity of peer review.We strongly feel that our paper deals with an important topic on....

We have also noticed the relative articles mentioned in your reply,but we put forward a completely different standpoint in our paper.We found that(1)...;(2)...;(3)....Thus,our paper has achieved a major break-through as it is the first time to testify that....

It would be much appreciated if you could reconsider to process peer review of our manuscript.I am looking forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely yours,(www.daowen.com)

例2:对审稿人误解文章内容或审稿意见中部分观点的申辩

Dear Editor,

Thank you very much for your hard work in processing our manuscript.We have carefully read the comments from the reviewer(s).Unfortunately,we notice that the reviewer(s)had misunderstood in several occasions,which may directly lead to your decision.Here,we would like to show some examples to you:

(1)...;(2)...;(3)....

We would greatly appreciate it if you would send this manuscript and our rebuttals to an additional unbiased reviewer.Thank you for your kind consideration.

Sincerely yours,

免责声明:以上内容源自网络,版权归原作者所有,如有侵犯您的原创版权请告知,我们将尽快删除相关内容。

我要反馈